Opening the backdoor to restraint: the 2026 Supreme Court Judgment
By Alexis Quinn, RRN Manager
A plain language version of this article is available here.
The June 2026 UK Supreme Court judgment (A Reference by the Attorney General for Northern Ireland) changed the legal landscape of care in England and Wales. It overturned the 2014 Cheshire West ruling, deciding that individuals aged 16 and over who lack formal legal mental capacity can still give valid consent to their care and living arrangements through everyday wishes and feelings.
Under the Mental Capacity Act, a formal assessment will have likely determined that an individual lacks the mental capacity to weigh up risks, understand choices, and make complex decisions about their safety and care. Yet, under this Supreme Court standard, the same person is credited with the legal capacity to ‘consent’ to a potentially restrictive, controlled environment simply because they do not fight back or shout.
The Legal Reality vs. Practical Risk
While the narrative suggests that a person who appears passive or does not actively protest will automatically be deemed to have consented, this requires careful qualification. The Supreme Court does not establish that passivity automatically amounts to consent. Grounded in European human rights approaches set out in Engel v The Netherlands and Guzzardi v Italy, court judgments demonstrate that no single factor is ever determinative on its own.
The Court notes that valid consent is an ‘autonomous concept’ distinct from domestic legal capacity. A person who lacks legal capacity but has a "basic understanding of their living circumstances" and "manifests their acceptance" of those arrangements should have their views respected when assessing deprivation of liberty under Article 5. Furthermore, the effect of restrictions on an individual (including compliance and the lack of objection if they are capable of objecting or giving tacit agreement) is relevant to assessing the objective element of confinement.
In plain English: This means that just because someone doesn't have official legal capacity to sign contracts or make big life decisions, the law still says they can show agreement or disagreement with their daily life if they have a basic grasp of where they are and what is happening.
Crucially, where there is serious doubt, no inference of valid consent should be drawn. As the judgment emphasises:
"If the individual is capable of expressing a view and there is serious doubt about their attitude, no inference should be drawn."
In plain English: This means that if staff or professionals are genuinely unsure whether a person truly wants something or is just going along with it, the law says you must never assume they have given consent.
Case Studies: Passivity or Choice?
To an outsider walking into a care home or a supported living placement, a quiet environment where individuals sit without shouting or obvious distress can look like peace and contentment. Without external scrutiny, there is no one forcing services to ask why that quietness exists.
For many individuals with learning disabilities, autism, or dementia, what might look like peaceful agreement may be the result of psychological survival adaptations:
- Jenni spent years discovering that expressing unhappiness, trying doors, or protesting against an unwanted routine would change nothing. She gradually stopped trying. Her passivity was a learned adjustment to an environment where resistance had proven useless.
- Ammah depended on a closed system for his most basic survival, attaching himself to whatever care routines, staff members, or restrictive boundaries were handed to him. His compliance was driven by an underlying fear of abandonment or instability, meaning he smiled, nodded, and accepted coercive care.
Jenni and Ammah’s worlds had been shrunk down to locked spaces, enforced bedtimes, regimented schedules, and restraint - which was the only reality they knew. Because they have never experienced self-direction or open choices, they could not protest the imposed restrictions.
Increased Restrictive Practices and Systemic Vulnerabilities
Without the legal safety net of formal oversight, services are losing a way to ensure accountability, creating a risk that restrictive practices will quietly multiply, disguised as ordinary, consensual living. Areas of concern and vulnerability include:
- Who is most at risk? The judgment creates a greater scope for institutional, psychological, cultural, and socioeconomic inequalities to influence how consent is identified, interpreted, and recorded. Individuals who lack resources, confidence, social connections, or independent advocacy are disproportionately affected. People with educated, well-connected families and financial resources are far better placed to challenge restrictive arrangements than those experiencing poverty, language barriers, social isolation, or limited knowledge of their rights.
- Systemic Pressures: In under-resourced health and social care systems, apparent acceptance risks becoming a reflection of institutional expectations rather than authentic choices. Resource-led decision-making, cultures of risk-aversion, and paternalism are already recognised problems where individual wishes are routinely subordinated to clinical or financial pressures. The CQC’s State of Care report warned that when services stop recognising restrictions, they become part of the culture, frequently documented alongside unlawful impositions.
- Environmental Restraint: Locked exit doors, restricted access to kitchens, being told to stay in particular spaces, and perimeter barriers that are no longer classified as a deprivation of liberty simply because the resident does not physically push against them.
- Chemical Restraint: Overmedication and sedation administered without complaint.
- Blanket Rules: Enforced bedtimes, standardised wake-up schedules, rigid institutional menus, and regulated or missing meaningful activity imposed under the banner of ‘practical care routines’.
- Psychological and Cultural Restraint: Doing things under implied coercion (e.g., if you do not do X, Y will happen), or having items removed or rewarded based on behavior, driven by institutional dependency and fear.
- Surveillance: Movement-tracking sensors, wearable alarms, and subtle behavioral conditioning that monitor a person's movements without scrutiny.
Because the individual does not outwardly protest, these restrictions might not be identified, challenged, audited, or reviewed.
Attending to Restraint in Your Setting: Areas of Opportunity
While the legal distinction between acquiescence and valid consent risks being lost in everyday practice, proactive services can transform culture by embracing clear opportunities:
- Cultural Transformation (6 Core Strategies - Huckshorn, 2005): Leaders should recognise that a care package lacking a formal deprivation of liberty authorisation is not automatically free of restraint. Restraint reduction reviews must apply to all hidden or unmonitored practices.
- Internal Auditing: Internal data collection should ensure that zero-restraint settings are actively audited and monitored.
- Independent Advocacy: Independent advocacy (including support from family and friends) must be explicitly embedded where formal legal safeguards are weakened.
- Rights Awareness: Staff must ensure people using services and their families are given accessible, clear information about their rights and the use of force.
- Staff Training: Staff must be trained to recognise that a lack of outward protest is not consent, but frequently a sign of exhaustion, adaptation, institutional dependency, or systemic compliance.
- Relationship-Based Support: Proactive support should equip staff to support individual agency, meaningful community participation, and actively dismantle environmental gating and blanket rules.
- Independent Challenge: Regular independent reviews questioning why any restriction remains in place must become the undisputed status quo.
Final thoughts
Let’s be alert to the possibility of normalising restrictions as an invisible feature of care without any right of challenge. Although the Supreme Court has acknowledged the legal distinction between acquiescence and valid consent, we must be concerned that this distinction may be lost in everyday practice. The silence from the government is deafening in a system desperate for guidance, creating a real risk that restrictive practices become progressively normalised, less visible, and less subject to independent scrutiny.